To rise for
Chow Down On These
Totes Delish
Smooth & Refreshing
Get Baked On
Cream Of The Crop
Can't Get Enough
Frozen Treats
Oh My
Other Sweets!
Sweet E's
Worth Eating Out At
a food blog by erin
more about me contact me
wafoodie on foodgawker
wafoodie on tastespotting
Follow on Bloglovin

Get recipes in your inbox!


Healthy Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake

Why eat a boring peanut butter sandwich for lunch when you can instead drink a peanut butter sandwich in cool liquid form?


That sounds a tad gross now that I think of it. That question makes it sound like I put a sandwich in the blender with some ice cubes. Not the case. It’s a riff off my healthy milkshake that uses a standard base of Greek yogurt and frozen banana to make a nutritious, protein-packed “milkshake.” This version in particular is a protein powerhouse courtesy of those ingredients and the addition of a heaping spoonful of peanut butter. Never having been a fan of grape jelly, I used fresh strawberries to get the flavor of strawberry jelly into the smoothie, and it really hit the spot on that hot afternoon.

I was never a huge fan of PB&Js growing up (“hold the jelly, double the peanut butter, please” was my mantra to live by), but recently these bars and a fried peanut butter sandwich (omg ridiculous even split 3 ways) from the Bite of Seattle festival a few weeks back and my mind has been changed. You seriously have no idea how excited I was to try a fried PB&J sandwich. It was a little embarrassing. Actually a lot embarrassing now that I think about it because it was pretty much all I could talk about before we hit up the festival. I felt a little guilty after eating my part of it, and I really started craving more peanut butter and jelly afterwards; however, with this smoothie, you don’t have to feel guilty at all.

Fun fact: the most popular flavor of jelly/jam is grape followed by strawberry, then raspberry. We learned this at trivia night. Our table had a big debate over raspberry or blackberry. Both Dustin and I voted for raspberry, and we were RIGHT!

Healthy Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake

  • 1 banana, cut into chunks and frozen
  • 1/3 cup non-fat vanilla Greek yogurt
  • 8 medium strawberries + 1 for garnish
  • 1 tablespoon peanut butter
  • splash of milk
  1. Combine all of the ingredients in a blender and blend until smooth. 
  2. Garnish with fresh strawberry.


It's lonely around here...

Get in on the conversation